If members aren’t showing up in Mailchimp the way you expect, turn on the API call log to see exactly what the Add On sends and how Mailchimp responds. This page also covers fixes for the most common setup issues.
Table of contents
Log API Calls
- Navigate to Settings > PMPro Mailchimp in the WordPress admin.
- Set Log API Calls? to Yes and click Save Settings.
- Repeat the action that isn’t working, such as a test checkout or a profile update.
- Download the log file using SFTP or your host’s file manager. The full path shows below the Log API Calls? setting. By default, the file is in the
wp-content/plugins/pmpro-mailchimp/logs/folder and namedpmpromc-log-followed by a random string and.txt.
Each entry starts with the date and time. The log records:
- The name and ID of each audience being updated.
- The data sent for each contact: email address, status (subscribed, pending, or unsubscribed), and merge field values, including names, membership levels, and any fields you add with custom code.
- Mailchimp’s response, either “No errors detected.” or the error count and details.
If WP_DEBUG is turned on for your site, the Add On also writes a short line to the WordPress debug log when it can’t connect to Mailchimp or when Mailchimp returns an error. Developers can move the log file to another location with the pmpromc_log_path filter.
Common Issues
The Settings Page Says “No audiences found.”
The Add On couldn’t load audiences from Mailchimp. Check that your API key was copied in full and hasn’t been disabled in your Mailchimp account. If Mailchimp rejected the key, the error message at the top of the settings page shows Mailchimp’s response. Also confirm your Mailchimp account has at least one audience.
Some Audiences Are Missing From the Settings Page
The Add On loads up to 15 audiences from your Mailchimp account. If you have more than 15, developers can raise the limit with the pmpro_addon_mc_api_fetch_list_limit filter.
Members Aren’t Added to a New Audience
The Add On keeps a saved list of your Mailchimp audiences and skips updates for any audience that isn’t on it. That list refreshes each time you load Settings > PMPro Mailchimp. After you create an audience in Mailchimp, reload the settings page, then assign the new audience and click Save Settings.
Existing Members Aren’t in Mailchimp
Saving the settings doesn’t sync members who are already on your site. Members are added when they check out, change levels, or update their profile. To add everyone now, export a CSV for each level and import it into Mailchimp.
Opt-in Lists Don’t Appear at Checkout
The opt-in section only appears when at least one audience is checked under Opt-in Audiences and the Add On can connect to Mailchimp with your API key. If you see “No audiences found.” on the settings page, fix the connection first.
New Contacts Show as Pending
Require Double Opt-in? is set to Yes (All audiences). Contacts stay pending until they click the confirmation link in Mailchimp’s opt-in email. Set it to No to subscribe new contacts right away.
Contacts Were Unsubscribed From an Audience
Check the Unsubscribe on Level Change? setting. With either Yes option, members are unsubscribed from a level’s audiences when they lose that level. Members are also removed from your non-member audiences when they gain a level, whatever this setting is. If you also use an audience for people who subscribe outside of WordPress, consider setting this to No. See What Happens When a Membership Level Changes.
Get Support From Our Team of Experts
Have a question about how to use this feature? Our Support Page outlines three ways to get support.
Our Max plans include hands-on help customizing your membership site and implementing new features. Upgrade to PMPro Max now »
Last updated on November 13, 2026

